3 Pastoral Observations about the SCOTUS 5-4 Decision

In an historic decision, the Supreme Court of the United States handed down a verdict Friday that makes it legal for same-sex couples to marry in all 50 States.
In the first 24 hours following the announcement, news outlets and social media platforms exploded with activity. Christian reactions have run the gamut from disappointment and concern on one end of the theological/denominational spectrum to gratitude and celebration on the other end.
While this landmark decision will most certainly be debated for years to come, I want to offer three observations from the heart of one pastor to his congregation as we all seek to maintain a steady measure of perspective and confidence amid such a rapidly changing culture.

  1. We are living in a 5-4 world.

It is telling that the high court’s decision was a narrowly divided decision. It’s a split that seems to mirror the rest of the nation, not only on this issue but so many others as well. Race. Politics. Economics. Ethnicity.
There are great chasms around us, between us, and (if we are honest) within us when it comes to the most sensitive matters of our time. That’s the nature of living in a broken world.
We are given a poetic glimpse of this reality at the end of the third chapter of Genesis. There, in Genesis 3:8-24, after the story of the “fall,” the ancient text describes the various gradations of division that characterize a post-edenic world. There is separation/division between humans and animals (enmity between Eve and serpent); separation between humans and humans (Eve and Adam are clothed, and are no longer “naked and unashamed”); and perhaps most tragically, division between humans and God (the sad expulsion from Eden).
It is no surprise a nation or a people divide along ideological, political, theological lines. It’s what we do. We live in a 5-4 world.
The question with which the church of Jesus Christ must grapple is this:
In an era of such polarization and posturing, what is the unique role of the church?
Some would say the role of the church in America, is to take a stand. Maybe so.
But among the particular “stands” that we take (whether they be in the camp of the “5” or the “4” on any given issue), the greater and higher calling of the church is to take a stand for civility, unity, mutual love and respect; never forgetting that we take our cues from the One who taught that it is the peace-makers who will be called children of God.

  1. This decision is not a threat to the religious liberty of Johns Creek Baptist.

It is important to remember that while Obergefell v. Hodges is primarily about a judicial interpretation of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution (equal protection under the law), it is the 1st Amendment which affords religious groups (like churches, synagogues, mosques, etc.) the protection to exercise their beliefs freely and un-coerced.
It is the first amendment, which reads (in part), “Congress shall make no laws respecting the establishment of religion, nor prohibit the free exercise thereof.” Applied here, churches will continue to make their own decisions about the kinds of marriages they perform, or don’t perform.
Indeed, the ruling itself went to great lengths to emphasize this point, stating, “Many who deem same-sex marriage to be wrong reach that conclusion based on decent and honorable religious or philosophical premises and neither they nor their beliefs are disparaged here.”
This is yet one more reason we can be grateful for our long heritage as Baptists for our historical championing of the separation of church and state. From our birth, over 400 years ago, we have fought, suffered and died for the religious liberties of all peoples (whether those peoples held the majority opinion or minority opinion).
We want neither a state that is controlled by the church, nor a church coerced by the state. The first amendment affords and protects that freedom.
For further resources on how to interpret this decision through the lens of Religious Liberty, I highly recommend visiting the website of The Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty www.bjconline.org. Based in Washington D.C., our friends Brent Walker, Hollyn Hollman and team have developed a terrific variety of trustworthy resources that will prove helpful in understanding how this decision impacts churches and other faith-based organizations.

  1. Jesus never saw “issues.” He saw people.

Jesus never joined political movements, or waved a flag “for” this issue or “against” that. Indeed, some surely attempted to bait him to that end. But he insisted on the deeper/further conversation. He looked through the political/theological controversy de jour, and saw (truly saw) the human being behind the issue.
When it comes to how we respond to the swiftly changing culture around us, it is important for Christians to do the same. May we never forget that for many, this issue isn’t simply an issue; but rather it’s a son, a daughter, a brother, a sister.
Fact. When an issue has a name and a face, and both belong to a person you love, the conversation changes. Your internal dialogue shifts from political to personal.
And it must. Christly love insists on it.
These are serious times. Conversations like this one require (and deserve) a certain emotional intelligence and spiritual maturity from our Lord’s church. The character of our witness to the world is at stake.
May each of us, and all of us, seek to know the heart and mind of Christ in all these matters. May we be diligent and disciplined with our study and our commentary. May we find ways to express our most deeply held convictions in ways that convey the same dignity, compassion, authenticity and class as the One who welcomed everyone to his banqueting table.
Shaun King
Senior Pastor
Johns Creek Baptist Church

12 Comments. Leave new

  • Beautifully stated.

  • Pat Appleton-Cordell
    July 2, 2015 11:40 am

    Very well said !

  • Susan Hudson
    July 2, 2015 12:02 pm

    I hope JCBC will see the people not issues when gay couples come to worship at our loving church. Jesus loves all his children

  • Sheri Whitney
    July 2, 2015 3:19 pm

    I’m so happy to read “emotional intelligence and spiritual maturity” come from the pulpit of the church where I raised my children. I truly do believe that “our witness to the world is at stake”, and hope that we, as Christians, can show the world that we are convicted AND compassionate.

  • Sheilia Moss
    July 2, 2015 3:31 pm

    Thank you for stating these observations so well. Many of us have probably put a name and a face to this issue, as we have, that has brought into focus that we all are loved and welcomed by Christ.

  • Troy Hester
    July 2, 2015 4:33 pm

    I would like to hear a sermon on 2 Thessalonians 2, focusing particularly beginning with verse 11.

  • Thank you, Shaun! These are the thoughts on which we should focus, I believe.

  • Valerie Richardson
    July 2, 2015 5:39 pm

    Thank you, from the bottom of my heart, thank you! No matter the miles that separate, you continue to encourage and teach us! We fall into that group you mention that puts a beloved “face” to the issue. We have been struggling with where and how to stand firm without driving our dear daughters away; away from Christ, away from us. Your Godly insight has given me strength and direction. Thank you! I can’t wait to show your post to Bobby. ❤️❤️

  • Valerie Richardson
    July 2, 2015 6:28 pm

    Thank you! From the bottom of my heart, thank you! No matter the miles that separate, you continue to teach, comfort and encourage us! We fall into that group of Christians for whom the issue has beloved faces. We have been struggling with how to stand firm without driving our precious loved ones away; away from Christ, away from us. Your Godly words have encouraged and comforted me while continuing to point me toward Christ to give me the words for each new conversation we will have with our beloved daughters!

  • Beautiful. Thank you.

  • We do not worship a 5/4 God. Love the sinner, hate the sin. Romans 1: 26-27 and Leviticus 20:13… do a thorough job of defining the sin. Welcome the repentant sinner, such as am I and the rest of us, with emphasis on “repentant”. The progression of “abhor”, “tolerate”, “embrace” applies here. “Don’t ask, don’t tell” might be appropriate.


      July 8, 2015 8:21 am

      YES! This is so well said. THE CHURCH needs to stay focused upon CHRIST and our appointed MISSION… thank you Pastor Shaun for keeping us Centered on our Purpose.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed